Categories
Essay

Answer or Knowledge?

What follows is a quotation from a recent article The Guardian by Sophie McBain. She in turn quotes Michael Gerlich of the Centre for Strategic Corporate Foresight and Sustainability:

Like many researchers, Gerlich believes that, used in the right way, AI can make us cleverer and more creative – but the way most people use it produces bland, unimaginative, factually questionable work. One concern is the so-called “anchoring effect”. If you post a question to generative AI, the answer it gives you sets your brain on a certain mental path and makes you less likely to consider alternative approaches. “I always use the example: imagine a candle. Now, AI can help you improve the candle. It will be the brightest ever, burn the longest, be very cheap and amazing looking, but it will never develop into a lightbulb,” he says. To get from a candle to a lightbulb you need a human who is good at critical thinking, someone who might take a chaotic, unstructured, unpredictable approach to problem solving. When, as happen in many workplaces, companies roll out tools such as chatbot Copilot without offering decent AI training, they risk producing teams of candle-makers in a world that demands lightbulbs.”

Knowledge – having knowledge – is incredibly important, so that when you hear something that’s questionable or maybe fake, you think, “Wait a minute, that contradicts all the knowledge I have that says otherwise, right?”

By Chris

Poet and writer: I have travelled the world in the Merchant Navy, worked on the farm where I now live, and re-invented myself as an information scientist. Born in Sussex, I moved to Swansea and have lived in the same farm cottage in mid-Wales for almost 50 years.

I have three collections of poems in print, Mostly Welsh, Book of the Spirit and the recent Lost Time. Although initially entirely focussed on poetry, my writing has branched into short stories and my first full length work of fiction, The Dark Trilogy and the collection of short stories - When I Am Not Writing Poetry - are also available.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *